Researching Usability

Mobile library survey report

Posted on: December 15, 2010

In November we ran a survey to all students at the university to investigate mobile demographics among students, Internet habits and attitudes towards mobile library services. The survey ran for two weeks and in that time 1,716 students responded. This was helped by an incentive prize draw of £50 Amazon vouchers – very attractive at this time of year.

In addition to demographic data and data on student’s mobile device, students were also asked about their mobile Internet habits and specifically their exposure to mobile university and library services. Finally they were asked which of the proposed mobile library services they would find most useful. The survey was loosely based on the research conducted by Information Services (IS) in March 2010 on mobile university services. Doing so allowed some comparisons to be made while also investigating mobile library services in-depth. Findings from the IS Survey can be found here: http://www.projects.ed.ac.uk/areas/itservices/integrated/ITS045/Other_documents/MobileSurvey2010.shtml.

The survey is part of the wider research within the UX2.0 project and relates to Objective 3 (deliverable 5.3) which is to evaluate the user experience in specific contexts involving real user communities. The quantitative data gathered from the survey will be supplemented by the focus group planned at the start of next year. The findings from the survey will help to shape the direction of the focus group which in turn will hopefully support the findings from the survey. Check back for a report on the focus group in the near future.

Some of the headline findings are provided below. The full report can be viewed here: http://bit.ly/ux2mobilesurvey.

  • 66.5% of students surveyed own a smartphone. This is an increase of 17.3% from the IS survey in March 2010.
  • Apple iPhones accounted for 21.9% of smart handsets, followed closely by Nokia at 20% and Samsung at 15.3%.
  • 68% of students have pay monthly contracts.
  • 74% students have either a contract that provides unlimited access to the Internet or provides sufficient access to meet their needs.
  • Services which students access online most frequently (several times a day or daily) are websites in general, email and social networks.
  • Activities which students are least likely to carry out on their mobile handsets regularly included downloading content and uploading images to photo sharing networks.
  • The biggest frustrations students experience using the Internet on mobile handsets included slow or limited Internet connection speeds, poorly designed mobile websites or websites without a mobile compatible website and the limitations of using a small screen with small buttons.
  • The highest proportion of students surveyed stated that they had not tried to access library services using their mobile device.
  • The top 3 potential University library services which students would find most useful would be:
    • Search library catalogue
    • Reserve items on loan
    • View your library record – see your charges summary and which books are reserved, requested, booked and loan

It was interesting to find that over half of students surveyed had not tried to access library services on their mobile device. It does seem that students use their mobile for other University services such as student email, the MyEd student portal and Web CT as well as other general university information such as shuttle bus timetables. Perhaps a mobile optimised library website with useful and easy accessible information would encourage students to use library services on the move more often. That coupled with effective communication that these services exist for mobile devices.

Students do seem open to the idea of mobile library services being useful, with the most useful being access to library records, the ability to search the library catalogue and databases, reserve items on loan and locate a shelf mark. However, the usefulness is dependent on the implementation of such services as many students reported that websites not optimised for smaller screens can be very difficult to use.

Limitations of smaller screen:

“It is slower than a computer and the screen is too small for a full-sized website. The library should have a special mobile website which does not take long to load and is easy to navigate on a small screen.”

Implementation of mobile websites:

“Websites should be tailored in order to be suitable for rendering on small screens. Endless scrolling makes for bad usability.”

Percentage of students who rate each library mobile service as “Very useful” or “Generally useful”

Rank % Library Service
1. 93 View your library record – see your charges summary and which books are reserved, requested, booked and loaned
2. 92.5 Search library catalogue
3. 90 Reserve items on loan
4. 89 Search library databases
5. 87 Locate a shelf mark
6. 84.5 Check PC availability in library
7. 82 Request an item through inter-library loan
8. 71 View maps of libraries
9. 67 Receive alerts relating to library information or services etc.
10. 64 Library Maps & Locations using GPS – find your way around University libraries
11. 58 Library statistics i.e. top books in different categories and popular searches
12. 55 Friend Locator – see where friends are in the library and contact them to meet up
13. 54 Read reviews others have left on items in the library
14. 52 Share items that you’ve found and/or read in the library that you think others will find useful
15. 49 Rate and review items from the library
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

del.icio.us bookmarks

Twitter feed

Archive

%d bloggers like this: